This Scottish summertime photograph, helpfully labelled on the back, celebrates the 35th (so-called coral) wedding anniversary of James Scobbie and Mina Laughland on July 3rd 1913, just before WW1. For photos from their diamond wedding celebrations in 1938 just before WW2 along with newspaper biographies, see the post on their diamond, gold and “ruby” anniversaries. A looming war is invisible in photographs like this, if we can resist the temptation to use hindsight to pour meaning into the expressions of the people in these gapless gatherings.
Looking back nostalgically to Edwardian days and to 1913 in particular remains a popular meme. This photograph could be from any number of costume dramas, films or TV shows, or could inspire yet another story that concentrates gradual ongoing social and political changes into the cataclysmic events following the so-called “long summer of 1913”. The British middle class myth is that this was a Golden Age before a generation was cut down and social changes unleashed. But things were never really golden all around: just ask the miners that provided the Scobbie family’s wealth. Nor were the social changes so sudden or unexpected. And it was not even that Britain was particularly disrupted by the Great War or by the 1920s’ Great Depression, in comparison to the rest of the world.
Back row: my grandparents George Hill Scobbie (1881-1961) and “Bertie” Scobbie (Elizabeth Bertie Stevenson, 1883-1949), his brother David Laughland Scobbie (1886-1978). (My sister points out that in many photos, Bertie does not look at the camera, but casts her eyes down.)
Middle row: John Hunter Logan (1860-1933), “Mabel” Logan (Mary Black Laughland Scobbie, 1879-1970), the celebrating parents “Mina” Scobbie (Williamina Black Laughland, 1852-1945) and James Scobbie (1853-1943), and David’s new* wife Marion Young Scobbie (nee Dick, 1884-1978).
Front row: Dr (David) McKenzie Newton (1881-1916), “Ebeth” Newton (Elizabeth Forrester Scobbie, 1884-1940), and his brother “Jack” (John Mackenzie Newton, 1879-1962).
Front row: George and Bertie’s eldest children: Hester (b. 1910) and Muriel (b. 1912).
James Percy Scobbie (1893-1909) as the “baby of the family” would have been 20 when this photo was taken, had he not died in an accident as a 16 year old, also in July. More happily, David and Marion had been married on 17th April, a couple of months earlier.
All the grandchildren
The other grandchildren of James and Mina were not present, but for completeness this page usefully lets me list them all in one place with relevant dates and names of marriage partners, and anything I know about jobs. Some of their children are still living so after that I have given only the numbers of sons and daughters and no further details. Please do get in touch, extended family, if you want me to add links or specific details.
In brief, organised by family, the five Logan children were Norman, (who married 2nd cousin Winifred),* Kenneth, Wilhelmina, Catherine, and William. David and Marion (not Marian) Scobbie never had children. David McKenzie and Ebeth Newton had just one surviving child, born after David’s death, Elizabeth Newton (b. 1916). Elizabeth was the prime researcher for James and Mina’s linked family trees. George and Bertie Scobbie’s other children were born later: Ebeth (b. 1914), Dorothy (b. 1918) and “Jim” (b. 1920).
David Newton is named on the back of the photo as “McKenzie Newton” which might mean he was known by his middle name to family and friends. “Jack” Newton, his brother, was the the John Newton who wrote seeking help from the government three years later when David died in Smyrna.
John and Mabel Logan lived in Hermitage Drive, Morningside, Edinburgh, very close to Greenbank Church where later Ebeth would be remarried to Robert Galloway, and some of their children also lived in Morningside.
I will gradually scan and add photos of as many of these people as I can, or give them specific pages, and link to there from here, with full names and dates.
- Rev. Norman Arthur Logan, 1900-1985. m. 1931 to (Jessie) Winifred Laughland Haldane,* 1911-2003. One daughter and one son. They lived 9/2 South Oswald Road Edinburgh then 12 Braid Avenue, Morningside Edinburgh. He was a Church of Scotland minister in Dailly, Bluevale Glasgow and Dunino.
- Kenneth Logan, 1903-1955, m. 1932 in Torphins to Kathleen May Mackie (1912-1991?). They had one daughter. He was a tea planter in Ceylon. They were divorced and he remarried Margaret Gardiner Veitch (1912-1999, nee Farquhar, previously married 1936 to Thomas Spence Veitch 1913-1990 then divorced), in 1954 in Morningside, Edinburgh. They lived in North Berwick, where Margaret seems to have remained. [Kenneth on GENi]
- Wilhelmina Black Laughland Logan, 1905-1984, m. 1934 in Greenbank Church, Morningside, to Alexander Reid Borrie, ~1881 – 1952.** He was an engineer and jute mill manager, Calcutta. The couple had one daughter and two sons. [Alexander on GENi and see the note ** below]
- Catherine Stewart Paterson Logan, 1906-1984). m. 1943 at St John’s Church Stanmore London to Neil MacMartin Stewart. They had two sons. Neil was a Lieutenant in the RCNVR (O-70220) from 21/05/1940. In 1945 he was in command of HMCS Lauzon (K371) as a convoy escort.
- William Stewart Paterson Logan, 1909-1968, Master of modern languages at The King’s School Macclesfield. Unmarried, I think.
- Hester Mary Black Scobbie, 1910-1989, m. 1937 in Bearsden South Church, Glasgow, to (Philip) Ernest Michelson Hutton, 1908-1988. One daughter and three sons. Ernest was an English teacher in Edinburgh and had been born in Myanmar (Burma). [Ernest on GENI which leads to more on the Huttons]
- Muriel Williamina Laughland Scobbie, 1912-2001, m. 1938 in Bearsden Glasgow to John Martin Mackay, 1899-1970. John was a lawyer and sheriff substitute in Dumbarton. Two sons. [John on GENi]
- Dr. Elizabeth Bertie Stevenson Scobbie, 1914-1994, m. 1947 in Beardsen Glasgow to William Alexander Barr (no dates), one son. Ebeth was a pediatrician. “Bill” was a chartered accountant and his family had also lived on Manse Road.
- Dorothy Hill Scobbie, 1918-2003. Dorothy was vice principal of a college of domestic sciences in Farnborough, and a weaver in Peebles. She was unmarried and lived with Ruby Minnie Frances (?) Hardy most of her life (~1914-2003) – Ruby has a great family history story of her own!
- Dr. James Stevenson Scobbie, 1920-1995, m. 1945 New Kilpatrick PC, Manse Road Bearsden to Sarah McMillan Black (1922-2012). Two daughters and two sons including the author of this site. Jim was a General Practitioner in Glasgow, and Sadie a registered nurse. [Sadie on GENi]
- David McKenzie Newton, 1914-1914, died in Roumelie Hisar, Istanbul, in infancy.
- Dr Elizabeth McKenzie Newton DA, 1916-2011, m. 1947 in Crown Court Church London to John Bernard Mitchell (no dates). One son and one daughter. Elizabeth was a consultant anaesthetist. She undertook all the basic research on the Scobbie-Laughland family: she has inspired me to follow her lead.
To finish, here are the parents and four children again, as children, this time 21 years previously in 1892 (the year before James Percy was born). This image appears also over on Ebeth’s page.
NOTES and LINKS
* Winifred was Mina’s sister Jessie’s grand-daughter, so both she and Norman were great grandchildren of Rev. David Laughland and Mary Black aka 2nd cousins.
** Extra detail according to Annette Marie Collins‘s research on Geni, (whose work comes down the Laughland side from Young and Laughland in Stewarton to Rev. David Laughland – Mina’s father: “At the time of his second marriage  Alexander Reid Borrie was a widower living in Calcutta India and working as the Manager of Central Hydraulic Jute Press. Alexander was 53 years and his wife Wilhelmina Black Laughland Logan was a 29 year old spinster.” Died: 4 Oct 1952 in Edinburgh. Note: Calcutta, India, was then the capital of the Raj India (now Kolkata, the capital of West Bengal). Central Hydraulic Jute Press according the The Calcutta Times of 25 March April 1936 was one of 31 licensed non-seasonal companies, and was based at 243 Upper Chitpur Road). [Here is a contemporary company/product that sounds similar.] (Raw jute is pressed to help form fibres, which is then processed to be used for sacking and rope, and Kolkata is still a major centre.)
*** Ebeth Newton (nee Scobbie) re-married in 1930 to Robert Galloway at Greenbank, Morningside, which was the Logan’s church. She lived some of the time with her sister, I think, and presumably met widower Robert who lived nearby at church. As for Jack Newton, after a little extra research I seem to have to have found more information – see here on David’s background.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b02m7fzt “The Long Summer”, part of “1913: The Year Before” presented by Michael Portillo
Sources & to-do list
The GENi site reports a lot of research independent from mine/Elizabeth Mitchell’s, by Annette Marie Collins and Gordon Meiklem Thomson. They have contributed material on the Laughlands, Borries, Logans, and Huttons. Most of the material on this page was sourced by Elizabeth up to 30 years ago, and a lot has been more recently checked by me with additional material added beyond the bare names and dates and occupations.
Annette and I are 5th cousins. She is descended from David Young, her gr-gr-gr grandfather, while I am descended from Elizabeth Young, my gr-gr-gr grandmother (and Mina Laughland’s paternal grand-mother). Her research shows they were siblings., and that our common ancestors were therefore their parents William Young (1755-1855) and Janet Calderwood from Stewarton, Ayrshire, our great x4 grandparents. [William on GENi] [Rev David Laughland and family on GENi in a tree of nearly 1000 linked people]. For a few notes on David Laughland by me, see the diamond, gold and ruby page.
James’s diary mentions the Stewart-Logan wedding, and says Neil “McMartin” Stewart was the son of Dr George Grant Stewart of Cadboro Bay, Vancouver Island (and that Catherine was “S./O.” signals officer?) Neil can be found on http://www.nauticapedia.ca (under “macmartin”)
Lots of Haldane stuff to follow up later, at https://www.myheritage.com/site-37660871/haldane posted by Alex Haldane (https://www.myheritage.com/member-68956232_37660871/alex-haldane) – Alex, if you see this, do get in touch! You are my 2nd cousin, once removed. Your gr-gr-gr grandparents are Rev. David Laughland and Mary Black, who are my gr-gr-grandparents.